• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant: Authentic Italian Dining Experience

At Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant, we celebrate the heart and soul of Italian cuisine in a warm, casual atmosphere. Located in Mayfield Heights, Ohio, our restaurant emphasizes authenticity, offering a range of dishes from perfectly cooked seafood to hearty pasta and indulgent desserts. Dine with us for lunch or dinner, and enjoy specialties like our Zuppa Di Pesce or the beloved Linguini Carbonara. With vegan options, kid-friendly meals, and outdoor seating, we cater to diverse preferences. Arrabiata's is not just a place to eat; it’s a gathering spot for family and friends to savor great food, making every visit a memorable experience.

Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant at a glance

  • Address 6169 Mayfield Rd Mayfield Heights, OH 44124 United States
  • Phone (440) 442-2600
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

Thomas Daniel
5

Eating here felt like a step back to the 1970's when small neighborhood Italian restaurants were the norm, and everyone who came in was known to everyone eating there. Italian is overheard at the bigger tables and from regulars. Food was served hot, and the restaurant has it's own uniquely flavored pasta sauce. Crowded, but in a good friendly way. A refuge for those seeking warmth, comfort, and a wonderful meal. Take your time to soak it all in.

David Blumberg
5

Tremendous Restaurant!!! Food was top notch delicious- had the Veal Parm and the Hot Antipasto with Calamari. My only negative is that the restaurant was dark inside for the ambiance. I much prefer light!!! Do the dark thing later at night say after 7PM, not at Lunch. I was there with my Fiancé so ambiance is a thing, but not in the dark please. Food again - amazing!! Great prices as well. 10/10 food!!!

Matt K
5

Took my wife here for Valentine’s Day and the hostess got us a table immediately when we had a reservation. Sarah was a great and attentive server and got all our food in a reasonable amount of time. We’d love to come back

Brigette Dangos
5

We have been coming back because the food was delicious , great price and enough for two people. Love the warm bread & garlic butter that comes with dinner.

Emily Evans
5

Wow 10/10! Loved this place so much! Food was great and the vibes are really nice and relaxed- like going to family home for a home cooked meal. Delicious and enjoyable. Will be coming back!

Pat Hellriegel
5

Great Italian Restaurant! The food was superb! Service was great. Very noisy and we were there on a Wednesday evening. We've been there on weekends, and although reservations are recommended on weekends especially, even if you do have a reservation, plan on waiting. Not a whole lot of parking either. Only a couple/few handicap spots. If you don't mind the walk, you can also park on the side street.

Liam Dangelo
5

I came with my mother to this small family owned italian restaurant and it was amazing. I normally don’t write reviews but this one deserves it. We got the Hot Antipasto appetizer which was phenomenal. For my entree I had the chicken dagnese and it was amazing. The Dagnese sauce was incredible with amazing taste. My mother ordered the tortellini derosa which she loved. I definitely recommend this place, service was great, and to top it off the portions were huge.

Jesse Temple
5

I went to school with the guys who started this place many years ago and used to eat here all the time. After moving farther away, I hadn’t been back in at least 10 years. I finally stopped in again recently and it was just as good as I remembered. The food was amazing, the service was great, and it was nice seeing a lot of familiar families still coming in. I also got to meet Paul’s daughter, the second generation helping run things now, and she took great care of us. You can tell she really cares about the business and the customers. It was great to see the same family atmosphere still going strong. I definitely won’t wait another 10 years to come back. The food is just too good not to crave.

Location

  • Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant
    Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant
    6169 Mayfield Rd Mayfield Heights, OH 44124 United States Hotline: (440) 442-2600

Welcome to Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled in Mayfield Heights, Ohio. This charming eatery offers a delightful escape into the heart of Italy, presenting a menu brimming with authentic flavors and hearty dishes. Whether you're seeking a casual dining experience with friends or a cozy dinner with family, Arrabiata's provides the perfect setting.

The ambiance is inviting, with a casual yet quiet atmosphere ideal for enjoying a meal without the hustle and bustle. Ideal for lunch or dinner, Arrabiata's accommodates all diners, including families with children and those looking to explore vegan or vegetarian options. The restaurant's commitment to inclusivity is refreshing, as it boasts a variety of dishes to cater to every palate.

  • Reservations: Easily book a table and avoid waiting.
  • Takeout & Delivery: Enjoy your favorites at home.
  • Outdoor Seating: Dine al fresco on those lovely days.
  • Happy Hour Specials: Great deals to unwind after a long day.
  • Full Bar: Quench your thirst with a selection of fine wines and other beverages.

The menu showcases a diverse range of offerings. Start your meal with the Hot Antipasto, featuring the delightful Fried Mozzarella Marinara and the beautifully presented Stuffed Hot Peppers. Each bite speaks volumes of the chef’s attention to detail and passion for Italian cuisine.

For seafood enthusiasts, the restaurant’s seafood dishes are a must-try! The Calamari Fritte is lightly floured and fried to perfection, providing a crunchy texture that is hard to resist. Meanwhile, the Mussels Possilipo served over linguini in rich tomato or white wine sauce resonates with the warmth of the Mediterranean.

Don’t overlook the pasta menu, where classics meet innovative twists. The Linguini Carbonara is a standout, harmonizing sautéed prosciutto and onions in a creamy alfredo sauce—pure comfort on a plate. Alternatively, the Lasagna, layered with cheese and rich meat sauce, embodies the essence of home-cooked Italian fare.

Whether dining in or enjoying a meal at home, Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant guarantees memorable Italian experiences. With attentive waiter service and a cozy setting, be prepared to savor each course. So, gather your friends and family, take a trip to 6169 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, or simply call (440) 442-2600 to secure your seat at this splendid establishment. Bon appétit!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards